When a major crisis breaks out for a bank or financial institution, the stock tends to follow a typical pattern in the first 30 days. Below is a summary based on historical cases:
📉 1. Immediate Crash (Days 1-5)
- Stock falls sharply (typically 10-30% in the first few days).
- Investors panic due to uncertainty and liquidity rushes out of the stock.
- Negative news headlines dominate media coverage, amplifying fear.
- Short sellers take aggressive positions.
✅ Example:
- Wells Fargo (2016): Fell ~10% in 3 days after the fake accounts scandal.
- IndusInd Bank (2024): Already fell ~15-20% in a few days after the derivative issue came out.
⏳ 2. Continued Selling & Negative Sentiment (Days 6-15)
- Stock remains under pressure, with occasional small bounces.
- More negative headlines emerge, possibly revealing deeper issues.
- Institutional investors may start selling or cutting positions.
- Credit rating agencies may downgrade the bank, further pressuring the stock.
- If the company remains silent, fear escalates, and selling intensifies.
✅ Example:
- ICICI Bank (2018, Chanda Kochhar scandal): Stock fell ~20% over 2 weeks, then stabilized.
- JP Morgan (2012, "London Whale" trading losses): Stock fell 22% in 10 days, then found a base.
📊 3. Stabilization & First Signs of Recovery (Days 16-30)
- Stock starts to find a base as panic selling slows.
- Valuation becomes very cheap, attracting deep-value investors.
- If the bank announces corrective actions (resignations, investigations, transparency), confidence slowly starts to return.
- Some short covering happens, leading to sharp relief rallies of 5-15%.
- However, full recovery is still far away—the stock remains volatile.
✅ Example:
- Axis Bank (2017, NPA shock): Recovered ~12% after 30 days, but remained volatile.
- Wells Fargo (2016): Gained ~8% in the 3rd week, but full recovery took much longer.
🔎 Key Takeaways:
1️⃣ Biggest damage happens in the first 5-10 days (10-30% fall).
2️⃣ Stock remains weak for the next 2 weeks, with occasional small rallies.
3️⃣ After ~30 days, stabilization begins, and a slow recovery process starts.
📈 What Could Happen to IndusInd Bank in the Next 30 Days?
- Already fell ~20% (could fall a bit more if more bad news emerges).
- Likely to stay volatile for 2-3 weeks, with negative headlines.
- If the bank addresses concerns transparently, stabilization could begin in 3-4 weeks.
- Short-term bounce of 5-10% likely after 20-30 days as panic selling slows.
- Full recovery will take months to years, depending on damage to reputation.
⏳ How Long Did Past Banking Scandals Take to Recover Fully?
Looking at historical cases, the time required for full recovery (returning to pre-crisis highs) varies based on the severity of the scandal, the bank’s response, and market conditions.
📊 Recovery Timelines of Major Banking Scandals
| Bank & Scandal | Stock Drop (%) | Time to Recover 40% | Time to Double (100%) | Time to All-Time High |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wells Fargo (2016) – Fake accounts scandal | 🔻 22% | ~2.5 months | ~1.5 years | ~2.5 years |
| JP Morgan (2012) – "London Whale" derivatives losses | 🔻 30% | ~3 months | ~1.8 years | ~3 years |
| American Express (1963) – Salad oil crisis | 🔻 50% | ~4 months | ~2 years | ~4 years |
| ICICI Bank (2018) – Chanda Kochhar scandal | 🔻 33% | ~2 months | ~1.2 years | ~3 years |
| Axis Bank (2017) – NPA shock | 🔻 25% | ~3 months | ~1.5 years | ~3 years |
🔎 Key Observations from Past Cases
✅ Fastest recovery: ICICI Bank recovered 40% in ~2 months due to improving financials.
✅ Longest full recovery: American Express took ~4 years to reclaim all-time highs.
✅ Common pattern: After a 40% gain, stocks pause for some time before doubling.
✅ Derivatives scandals (JP Morgan, IndusInd Bank) tend to recover slower than governance-related scandals.
📈 What This Means for IndusInd Bank?
- Time to recover 40%: ~2 to 4 months if negative news flow slows down.
- Time to double (100% rise): 1.5 to 2.5 years, depending on confidence restoration.
- Time to all-time high (~2000 INR): 3-4 years, assuming consistent growth.
📊 Estimating IndusInd Bank’s Future Targets
If IndusInd follows Wells Fargo (2016):
- 40% gain: ₹980 (in 2-4 months).
- 100% gain: ₹1,400 (in ~1.5-2 years).
- All-time high: ₹2,000+ (in ~3-4 years).
If IndusInd follows JP Morgan (2012):
- 40% gain: ₹980 (in ~3 months).
- 100% gain: ₹1,400 (in ~2 years).
- All-time high: ₹2,000+ (in ~3-4 years).
📊 Downgraded Banks in Our Study & Market Impact
| Bank & Year | Reason for Downgrade | Rating Agency | Stock Impact (30 Days) | Time to Recover |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wells Fargo (2016) | Fake accounts scandal & governance issues | S&P, Moody’s | 🔻 10% in first month | ~2.5 years to ATH |
| JP Morgan (2012) | $6B "London Whale" trading losses | Moody’s | 🔻 7% initially, 🔻 30% total | ~3 years to ATH |
| American Express (1963) | Salad oil crisis—financial instability | N/A (not rated back then) | 🔻 50% total | ~4 years to ATH |
| ICICI Bank (2018) | CEO Chanda Kochhar controversy, governance issues | Moody’s, S&P | 🔻 12% post downgrade | ~3 years to ATH |
| Axis Bank (2017) | Sharp NPA increase, asset quality concerns | Moody’s, S&P | 🔻 8% in first month | ~3 years to ATH |
🔻 What Happens If IndusInd Bank Gets Downgraded?
Based on past cases (Wells Fargo, JP Morgan, ICICI Bank, Axis Bank):
- Immediate stock price decline (5-15%) within the first month.
- Bond yields may rise, increasing borrowing costs for the bank.
- Depositor confidence may weaken, leading to slower deposit growth.
- Recovery could take 1.5-3 years, depending on management response.
📉 Stock Price Impact if Downgraded
- Short-term dip: ₹650-680 levels if negative news intensifies.
- Recovery phase (1-3 years): If fundamentals hold, ₹1,000-1,200 range over 12-18 months.
- Long-term upside (3+ years): ₹1,500+ if the bank executes well.
💡 Key Watchlist for Investors
✅ RBI’s stance—will it increase scrutiny or impose restrictions?
✅ Rating agency commentary—look for signals from Moody’s, S&P, CRISIL.
✅ Management’s response—how well they address governance & risk concerns.
No comments:
Post a Comment